Auschwitz, or Someplace Like It
Prominent people who make historical gaffes actually do us all a favor without meaning to. They send a generation of bright but uninformed pundits scurrying for reference material, the better to pile on the unfortunate gaffer -- and to make sure they don't make such a mistake themselves.
And so, as in this case, they will discover that "Auschwitz" is not the only name on the horror roll, and that "Buchenwald," officially a camp for POWs, dissidents, insurgents, and people from suspected minority groups, is on the list, too.
So, maybe people who only have known the Billy Joel version of history will get a little glimpse of something deeper. And maybe they will want to revisit afresh their assertions that Guantanamo Bay is exactly like a Nazi concentration camp.
And so, as in this case, they will discover that "Auschwitz" is not the only name on the horror roll, and that "Buchenwald," officially a camp for POWs, dissidents, insurgents, and people from suspected minority groups, is on the list, too.
Mr. TYLER McKENNEY PAYNE (British Soldier): I'm Tyler McKenney Payne of the ... (unintelligible). I live at Mansfield Woodhouse. I want to tell you a tale, just one tale, as there are many other horrible sights in the past days that I saw. I myself was guarding the milk store, and around this milk store was a screaming crowd of women with babies. I kept picking a few babies out and feeding them.
And one woman who was--I think she was mad, kept kissing my feet and clothing, so I took the baby from her. When I looked at the baby, his face was black and he had been dead for a few days. I couldn't come to say it was dead so I burst the milk can opened and poured milk down through its dead lips. The woman crooned and giggled with delight. I gave her the baby back and she staggered off and lay in the sun. And when I next looked, she was dead with the baby in her arms. So I put her in the stack of the dead bodies, 2 or 300 dead, and then I turned away. I was allowed to say that I'm a British soldier and it's not propaganda; it's the truth.
So, maybe people who only have known the Billy Joel version of history will get a little glimpse of something deeper. And maybe they will want to revisit afresh their assertions that Guantanamo Bay is exactly like a Nazi concentration camp.