Sunday, May 18, 2008

Lebanon

For an informed, and alternate-media, view of what just happened in Lebanon, the must-read articles are at, or linked from, Michael J. Totten's site.

Labels:

Sunday, December 02, 2007

Lying in Print

You don't need a degree in anything to do journalism. Until about 30 years ago, it was a job you could hook into right out of high school. You didn't even have to be good with interviews (you could be a rewrite man). You didn't even need to know how to type. I still don't.

But you did need some things. And you still need them. One is the ability to be clear and honest about information and where you got it. And more than a few of the people who want to be citizen journalists don't pay attention to that. Here's the latest example.

In retrospect, however, this is a case where I should have caveated the reporting by saying that I only witnessed a fraction of what happened (from a moving car), with broader details of what I saw ultimately told to me by what I considered then — and still consider to be — reliable sources within the Cedar Revolution movement, as well as insiders within the Lebanese national security apparatus.

The problem is not that you used sources, or even anonymous sources. The problem is, you didn't tell your readers you did so. And you conflated what they told you with what you saw, and passed it off as eyewitness reporting.

Why would a writer do this?

  • 1. To make his writing more compelling. It's the kind of sin committed by people who traditionally sneer at news reporters and who really want to be creative writers or riveting storytellers. All that detail of attribution -- "said an unnamed source close to the investigation who asked to remain anonymous," etc. -- really clots up the flow of your prose. And if you're telling people something, it's the thing that matters, not the source, right?

    At the same time, it makes you look like a real active heroic fact-gatherer, face-to-face with the harsh realities of the story, not some computer jockey working the phones and getting the picture second-hand from sources.

  • 2. When the narrative matters more to you than the facts. Here's one of the stories that tripped up the above writer. The part in boldface is the part he now acknowledges he got from someone else, and has never been confirmed:


BEIRUT – Hezbollah is rehearsing for something big here. Not sure what or when. But a few days ago, between 4,000 and 5,000 HezB gunmen deployed to the Christian areas of Beirut in an unsettling “show of force,” positioning themselves at road intersections and other key points throughout the city. Two additional objectives were achieved: First, the operation served as a probing action to determine local reaction. Second, it served as an exercise to gauge the time required (speed, synchronization, etc.) to achieve the key points and intersections.

Amazingly, there was no response from the police or the army.

HezB is also jamming cell-phone signals almost daily. Their lookouts are everywhere, at least from my vantage point, because they are watching the people I'm with and me.

HezB is also far better armed, equipped, and tactically proficient than most Americans might realize. They are terrorists to be sure: But they are also a very strong Iranian-trained guerrilla force here in Lebanon, and they seem to be getting a pass from far too many people in high places.

Last night, an anti-Hezbollah “weapons expert” said to me, smiling, “Lebanon needs about 25,000 U.S. Marines.”

The "between 4,000 and 5,000" thing, in fact, is about the only "fact" in there. The rest of it is narrative spun from that supposed fact. The unattributed statement that phone signals are being jammed -- and naming who is doing it (how? which signals? all of them? says who?)-- along with the ability to turn "they are watching me" to "they have lookouts everywhere" ought to be enough to raise anyone's red flag, unless you're reading to feed your narrative.

This editor's note is weasel words. To blame it on "[t]he Arab tendency to lie and exaggerate about enemies" is execrable. This is closer to the right tone.

Labels:

Tuesday, December 05, 2006

What the World Needs Now

[posted by Callimachus]

Here's a passionate, moving, and beautiful piece of life-story writing by Abu Kais. He tells, among other things, of seeing "a repulsive music video by a Lebanese singer I used to admire and respect: Julia Boutros."

Julia, a Lebanese resident of Dubai, felt a rush of excitement upon hearing one of Nasrallah’s speeches during the war, in which he addressed his fighters as his loved ones (Ahiba’i). So she turned the speech into a song.

In the video, Julia leads groups of children amid ruins, and children morph into masked fighters.

As a Lebanese Shia and a father, I was appalled by this video. Who gave Julia the right to prescribe a future of violence? As a critic of the July-August war, and someone who lived under Israeli and Syrian occupations, I was filled with anger at both regimes at various points of time. I will probably never forgive Israel and Syria for their crimes in Lebanon. But I will not prescribe death and "martyrdom" to my child.

Then he tells the stories of the parents and grandparents who raised him and taught him: All they endured in the blood-boltered 20th century and how they never swerved into the cult of death.

My grandparents are with me every minute of the day telling me to embrace life and look forward. They weren’t perfect people, but they did not allow anyone to stand in my school to tell me that the future is in sacrificing your life over a dead cause.

My grandmother would not appreciate that this singer is telling my child to take the door to death, when the door to life is wide open.

My grandparents would not appreciate a group of thugs hijacking the hope they carried in their hearts until their last day on earth. They would be sad that Shia youth are dying because to some, war does not end when the occupier leaves—it’s self perpetuating, a circle game where children grow up to be fighters, and new enemies are born every day.

Read it all, and cherish it.

Labels:

Thursday, August 24, 2006

France Steps Up

France steps up. As I read it, all it took was a little shame, a little assurance, and a lot of desire not to see the Italians take the lead.

BEIRUT (Reuters) - France said on Thursday it was ready to send an extra 1,600 troops to bolster a revamped U.N. force for Lebanon, bringing the total French contingent to 2,000 and making it easier to recruit other nations.

France initially offered only to double its force in Lebanon to 400, disappointing many U.N. diplomats who had expected Paris to provide the backbone of the mission.

However, President Jacques Chirac said France decided to dispatch many more troops after winning assurances from the United Nations that the troops would be able to defend themselves fully if they came under attack and could use force to protect civilians.

"Two thousand French troops will thus be placed under the United Nations in Lebanon. France is ready, if the United Nations wishes, to continue commanding this force," Chirac said in a televised address.

Italy, which had promised 2,000 to 3,000 troops, earlier said it had won U.S. blessing for its leadership of the force and that it was confident Europe, especially France, would firm up its so far limited military commitment.

Prime Minister Romano Prodi said President George W. Bush had told him by telephone of his "positive" view of Italy's offer to lead the force. He added Bush was also leaning on allies to offer troops.

The Bush administration later welcomed Chirac's offer.


I think this is great news, and I'm personally glad France lived up to my good opinion of her.

Labels: ,

Wednesday, August 16, 2006

Against Forgetting

Iam watching Israeli troops shuffle home in tears and without victory -- in a world where all know there is no draw, no tie, where everything short of catastrophic success for Israel is catastrophic failure for Israel.

Israel has existed longer than most of us have been alive. Its continuance is no more assured today than it was on day one. The same serpents still slither around the cradle -- no, the old ones have passed into senility and hatchlings bred in their rotten wombs now have sharper fangs, fouler poisons.

In Iran, Ahmadinejad framed the story of the month of Rajab, A.H. 1427, as it will be told throughout the Muslim world for a generation: "God's promises have come true," Ahmadinejad told a huge crowd. "On one side, it's corrupt powers of the criminal U.S. and Britain and the Zionists ... with modern bombs and planes. And on the other side is a group of pious youth relying on God." For a generation, at least.

Bashar is beaming.

"We tell them [Israelis] that after tasting humiliation in the latest battles, your weapons are not going to protect you not your planes, or missiles or even your nuclear bombs ... The future generations in the Arab world will find a way to defeat Israel."

Amid the rubble, Hezbollah's flag still flies. That would be enough. But the victory is just beginning. The "New York Times" reports:

Nehme Y. Tohme, a member of parliament from the anti-Syrian reform bloc and the country's minister for the displaced said that he had been told by Hezbollah officials that when the shooting stopped, Iran would provide Hezbollah with an "unlimited budget" for reconstruction.

In his Monday night victory speech, Hezbollah leader Sheik Hassan Nasrallah offered money for "decent and suitable furniture" and a year's rent on a house to any Lebanese who lost his home in the last month's war.

Across southern Lebanon hundreds of Hezbollah members began cleaning, organizing, and surveying damage in dozens of villages.

Hezbollah's reputation as an efficient grassroots social service network — as opposed to the government, regarded by many here as sleek men in suits doing well — was in evidence everywhere.

Hezbollah's strength, said Amal Saad-Ghorayeb, a professor at the Lebanese American University here who has written extensively about the organization, in large part derives from what she called "the gross vacuum left by the state."

Hezbollah wasn't a state within a state, she said, but "a state within a nonstate, actually."

Nasrallah's speech was interpreted by some on Tuesday as a kind of watershed in Lebanese politics establishing his party on an equal footing with the official government.


The "Chicago Tribune" reports today that in Tyre, "Hezbollah supporters were passing candy along the roadside and cheerily calling out 'Welcome Back' to returning motorists."

Another "Times" story reports on the returning refugees:

Dozens of yellow Hezbollah flags flew from the windows of cars heading south, and few of the returning exiles seemed to hold Hezbollah responsible for their troubles.

"This traffic — what right does Bush have to make us live like this?" said Bilal Masri, 50, who had just spent five hours on a 15-mile drive down the coast. Masri, a Sunni, works at a fuel storage plant that was bombed by Israel, but blames President Bush. "By what right did he bomb us?" he asked. "Bush says he likes democracy and human rights; where is democracy now?"

Before, he said, he hated Israel a little, but "now I truly hate it and want to cancel its existence."


What did he want to do when he only "hated" it "a little?" What sort of rational engagement by Israel, what sort of nuanced ripples of American foreign policy, will make a steady friend of that man?

And what have we allowed ourselves to forget?

Yes, perhaps Israel should have hit more quickly, harder, and on the ground; yes, it has run an inept public relations campaign; yes, to these criticisms and more. But what is lost sight of is the central moral issue of our times: a humane democracy mired in an asymmetrical war is trying to protect itself against terrorists from the 7th century, while under the scrutiny of a corrupt world that needs oil, is largely anti-Semitic and deathly afraid of Islamic terrorists, and finds psychic enjoyment in seeing successful Western societies under duress.

A world where even a professional writer of Jewish jokes in Britain blanches at what he hears on the streets:

There have always been anti-Semitic jokes. But you know times are changing when you go along to a stand-up show at the Pleasance Courtyard at the Edinburgh Fringe and you hear audience members shouting “Throw them in the oven” when the comic suggests kids should stop playing Cowboys and Indians and replace it with Nazis and Jews.

Stand-up comedy is as good a prism as any through which to look at the changing attitudes in our society. If my past few days are anything to go by then it is becoming increasingly acceptable to hate the Jews. Again.

I’ve seen two comics so far who have been happy to amuse their crowds with Holocaust gags. ... One was a left-leaning angry Australian conspiracy theorist, Steve Hughes, whose show The Storm is an assault on all things Western. “I want to bash Condoleezza Rice’s brain to bits and kill that f****** Jew Richard Perle.”


Here it comes again. Time to make a stand.

Labels: ,

Sunday, July 30, 2006

Thanks To Hezbollah

Lebanon's prime minister thanks Hezbollah for defending his country--not surprisingly, without mentioning that Lebanon was attacked because of the terrorist's group continuing presence and influence in that country in the first place and his government's inability to control its activities, including provocation of Israel.
Lebanese Prime Minister Fuoad Siniora expressed his 'gratitude' to Hizbullah and its leader Hassan Nasrallah for "sacrificing their lives for the country."

During a press conference held in wake of the Qana village incident in which 55 Lebanese were killed, Siniora asked: "Is Israel's mission to wipe out the Lebanese? It seems they want to kill all of us. One of those killed today is a baby just one day old. With its aggression, Israel is encouraging extremism."
...
He said that "in order to reach a general ceasefire Israel must pull back to its borders. Then, Lebanon will fulfill its obligations according to the seven clauses approved by the government."

Among others, the Lebanese government committed itself to an immediate ceasefire, the deployment of its army across all of Lebanon including the south, and the applying of a law according to which only the Lebanese army can carry weapons across the whole of the country.

The problem with this, of course, is that Lebanon has failed to keep its end of the bargain since Israel pulled out six years ago--and, in fact, have we not repeatedly been told that the Lebanese government can't do anything about Hezbollah? Isn't that partly why the Israeli attack has been characterized as unfair? How, then is Lebanon supposed to exert control over Hezbollah now, disarm its members and ensure that weapons are born only by the Lebanese army? Does the latter have power and authority now that it didn't before?

And even if the government miraculously and suddenly has a measure of control that it claimed it didn't so very recently, how credible can its promises be, not just in light of its actions and inactions over a number of years, but in light of Siniora's expressing his "full admiration for Nasrallah and all those who sacrifice their lives for Lebanon"?

It's hard to imagine Israel agreeing to a ceasefire that doesn't also include Hezbollah (and vice versa) given how far this down the path this engagement as gone. How can Siniora possibly think it helpful, at this juncture, to praise Nasrallah? Because it seems to me that in appearing to move closer to Hezbollah, the Lebanese PM is reducing incentive for an Israel to compromise, not increasing it. And it also bolsters the argument that part of what Israel feared to begin with was Lebanon's vulnerability to being co-opted by Hezbollah and its attitudes.

Of course, Siniora's got plenty of opinion on his side against Israel and on the side Hezbollah, which may explain his apparent confidence.

Tonight, I'm thinking that I was too upbeat earlier today--which sure isn't how it felt this morning. How did I forget rule #1 in the Mideast: Never underestimate how much worse things can get, and how quickly.

Labels:

Not A Gentleman's War, Nor Hope's Hook

This morning, as I (reader-iam) sat watching CNN and listening to a reporter relentlessly question the woman whom she was interviewing about the morality of Israel killing civilians, clearly under the assumption that Israel is cold-bloodedly, profligately "targeting" them for death and destruction, I happened to be reading this story featuring photos of Hezbollah, smuggled out of East Beirut and published in the Sunday Herald Sun (Australia).
The images, obtained exclusively by the Sunday Herald Sun, show Hezbollah using high-density residential areas as launch pads for rockets and heavy-calibre weapons.

Dressed in civilian clothing so they can quickly disappear, the militants carrying automatic assault rifles and ride in on trucks mounted with cannon.

The photographs, from the Christian area of Wadi Chahrour in the east of Beirut, were taken by a visiting journalist and smuggled out by a friend.
...
The images include one of a group of men and youths preparing to fire an anti-aircraft gun metres from an apartment block with sheets hanging out on a balcony to dry.

Others show a militant with AK47 rifle guarding no-go zones after Israeli blitzes.

Another depicts the remnants of a Hezbollah Katyusha rocket in the middle of a residential block blown up in an Israeli air attack.

The Melbourne man who smuggled the shots out of Beirut and did not wish to be named said he was less than 400m from the block when it was obliterated.

"Hezbollah came in to launch their rockets, then within minutes the area was blasted by Israeli jets," he said.

"Until the Hezbollah fighters arrived, it had not been touched by the Israelis. Then it was totally devastated.

How dare those Israelis! Immoral, unfeeling, disproportionate bastards, corrupt tools of the decadent, imperialistic West! Unlike Hezbollah, they fight with abandon, cynically tossing aside any notion of boundaries or respect for life along with the bodies of their victims.

Right?

Meanwhile:
[Sheikh Naim] Qassem, a founding member of Hezbollah in 1992 and deputy general secretary, claimed Sheikh Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah, Hezbollah’s leader, has remained in Lebanon and has not taken refuge outside the country as has been rumoured.

“The Israelis have said several times that they were targeting the general secretary and some of his leadership in bunkers because they are certain that they are indeed in Lebanon. Hezbollah’s leadership is used to being in the field.”

Qassem admitted Hezbollah had been preparing for conflict since Israel withdrew from south Lebanon in 2000. He claimed it had not been convinced that Israel’s aspirations in Lebanon were over, despite its withdrawal.

“The fact that Israel kept the Shebaa Farms (a strip of disputed land on the border), held on to the prisoners and its continuous reconnaissance flights over Lebanon were all indications of its aggressive intentions towards Lebanon,” he said.

Of course, Israel has proved Hezbollah's wisdom by responding to that group's continued presence and growth in influence in Lebanon over the past six years and refusing to ignore the fact that other parties to the brokered agreement that led to Israel's withdrawal from that tragic country had reneged in their commitments.

See? See? We told you that Israel was up to no good! It insists on responding to our ongoing provocation and stated desire for the Jewish state's elimination from the face of the earth!

As it happens, I've come to the opinion that it's more likely than not that Israel has made some fundamental miscalculations in its attack on Lebanon, most especially in terms of its timing, but also in an apparently overly optimistic assessment of both the desire of rank-and-file Lebanese for Hezbollah's expulsion and the strength and ability of Hezbollah itself. A good chunk of the rhetorical response from kibbitzers in the U.S., particularly with regard to calls for "striking while the iron is hot" in expanding war into other countries (however malign) has been irresponsible at best. And the handling of the situation by the U.S. and other governments has been remarkably unfocused, disorganized, and even tin-eared, given the pre-eminence of the Mideast situation over the past several years (not to mention the previous quarter century, at least).

All of that, however, is a far cry from assigning the majority of ultimate moral blame for the carnage, civilian or otherwise, in Lebanon to Israel, much less the U.S., Britain or the West generally, rather than Hezbollah, which appears to have little problem with swaddling itself in blankets of civilians.

After all, Israel may be be choosing where to aim its high-tech arrows, but Hezbollah is responsible for the calculated placement of the targets, and for cynically painting the bull's-eye as red as red can be.

Ah, but with the West's advantages, its vaunted values, its supposed superiority and strength, shouldn't it take the higher ground and condem Israel for letting fly? Shouldn't Israel, and its "puppet-masters" (a misnomer if ever there was one: The last thing that Israel should be considered is a puppet), answer to a higher set of rules and self-restraint?

Coincidentally, just before coming inside to check both cable news channels and the internet for updates this morning, I happened upon a reprint of a piece of dialogue from the 1943 film The Life and Death of Colonel Blimp (admittedly propaganda, but transcendent), cited in James Bowman's Honor: A History****:
"I read your broadcast (says Theo) [a former WWI German officer with whom the film's British main character, General Candy, had a duel way earlier in the century but ended up befriending], up to the point where you describe the collapse of France [in WWII]. You comment on the Nazi methods, foul fighting, bombing refugees, machine-gunning hospitals, lifeboats, lightships, bailed-out pilots and so on, by saying that you despised them, that you would be ashamed to fight on their side and that you would sooner accept defeat than victory if it could only be won by those methods."

"So I would."

"Clive, if you let yourself be defeated just because you are too fair to hit back, the same way they hit at you, there won't be any methods but Nazi nethods. If you preach the rules of the game while they use every foul and filthy trick against you, they'll laugh at you. They'll think you're weak, decadent. I thought so myself in 1919."

"I heard all that in the last war. They fought foul then, and who won it?"

"I don't think you won it. We lost it. But you lost something, too. You forgot to learn the moral. Because victory was yours, you failed to learn your lesson 20 years ago and now you have to pay the school fees again. Some of you will learn quicker than the others. Some will never learn it--but you have been educated to be a gentleman in peace and in war. But Clive, dear old Clive, this, this is not a gentleman's war. This time you're fighting for your very existence against the most devilish idea ever created by the human brain, Naziism, and if you lose there won't be a return match next year, perhaps not even for a hundred years."

Disheartening, that vision, but unfortunately resonant--as is this poem, which has been running through my head for several days:
Hope

I keep hanging up my hopes
On the signs of the seashore preparing itself
For the oncoming summer
The ring of sand doesn't care for the meaning of writing
Nor is the cycle of the wave visible to the naked eye.

I am a friend of the friend of the sea
And an enemy of the enemy of the land
Between these two there's nothing but air
Some of it melting in the speeding wind
Some of it slow as a tortoise.
Between speed and slowness
I inhale the loneliness that's left.

My watch has become useless for all
Except for the one who wears it
There's a time lag between the other side
Of the sea
And the other.

A place is marked only by the one who loves it
So Ill hang up my hopes
On the scaffold of distant hope
Once here once there
And when the right time comes
My watch will be left with no hands.
--Naim Araide


****(Bowman's book is a fine piece of work, and--in a first for me, I think--I recommend it heartily despite not having finished it yet. Far from being a polemic (which, frankly, I expected, and I'm delighted to be wrong), it's a thoughtful review of changing definitions of honor over time, and the struggles, both individual and aggregate, over and with evolving cultural attitudes toward the concept, in theory and practice. Yet (unlike my previous sentence!), it's neither dry nor highfalutin', but deftly explores its topic with reference both to history and art, especially literature, but not confined to it. Over my lifetime of reading widely and voraciously, I can think of relatively very few books which were so immediately relevant in myriad ways that I knew, within a few chapters, that I would be re-reading them--probably immediately upon completion--and pondering deeply. This is one.)

Labels:

Friday, July 28, 2006

A Hint Of Pause?

Israel decides against expanding its attack in Southern Lebanon, although it's calling up 30,000 of its reserves just in case.

Meanwhile:
The Israel Air Force on Thursday scored a successful direct hit against Hezbollah's missile command center deployed in Tyre, which has been primarily responsible for targeting Haifa and its surroundings. The regional command center was located on the 12th floor of a Tyre building that the IAF destroyed.
And:
Now, with hundreds of Lebanese dead and Hezbollah holding out against the vaunted Israeli military for more than two weeks, the tide of public opinion across the Arab world is surging behind the organization, transforming the Shiite group’s leader, Sheik Hassan Nasrallah, into a folk hero and forcing a change in official statements.

The Saudi royal family and King Abdullah II of Jordan, who were initially more worried about the rising power of Shiite Iran, Hezbollah’s main sponsor, are scrambling to distance themselves from Washington.

An outpouring of newspaper columns, cartoons, blogs and public poetry readings have showered praise on Hezbollah while attacking the United States and Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice for trumpeting American plans for a “new Middle East” that they say has led only to violence and repression.


Tempted to connect any dots?

Labels:

Tuesday, July 25, 2006

But You Let Us Get Away With It Before!

So does this mean Hezbollah might have thought twice before kidnapping the two Israeli soldiers had Israel smacked back hard sooner? That the group was expecting a more "proportional response," but is now--just like your classic playground instigator or troublemaker--mightily affronted, highly indignant, and defiantly self-righteous because its bluff got called and the provoked went on the offensive?
The truth is _ let me say this clearly _ we didn't even expect (this) response.... that (Israel) would exploit this operation for this big war against us," said Komati.

He said Hezbollah had expected "the usual, limited response" from Israel to the July 12 cross-border raid, in which three Israelis were killed.

In the past, he said, Israeli responses to Hezbollah actions included sending commandos into Lebanon to seize Hezbollah officials or briefly targeting specific Hezbollah strongholds.

He said the Shiite group had anticipated there would be negotiations on exchanging the Israeli soldiers for three Lebanese prisoners in Israeli jails, with Germany acting as a mediator as it did before.

Puts an interesting light on things, doesn't it? Even sort of suggests that perhaps some rethinking about the wisdom of Israel's reaction on the part of those who are just so absolutely certain that, long-term, terrorist groups will respond just as well or better to negotiation and accommodation as they do force. And that maybe, just maybe, there's at least a little bit of truth in the idea that terrorist groups--like those playground bullies--do tend to interpet what we call restraint and temperance as weakness and appeasement.

Oh, I know that's not the whole picture, and that the situation is more complex. Still, it seems to me that some serious, clear-eyed and sober re-evaluation is needed to combat overly wishful thinking in some quarters.

Labels:

Wednesday, July 12, 2006

Hezbollah Attack "Act Of War" By Lebanon?

[Updated at bottom.]

That's how Israeli P.M. Olmert characterizes it.
Seven IDF soldiers were killed Wednesday in a Hizbullah attack on IDF forces patrolling the Lebanese border, it was released for publication.

Three soldiers riding in a Hummer jeep were also killed, while two other soldiers in the same jeep were kidnapped.

Four other soldiers died when the tank in which they were riding rode over a bomb, which detonated in a massive explosion. The force of the blast ripped the tank apart, and IDF forces were searching for the remains. All of the soldiers' families have been notified.

Wednesday morning's attacks, which occurred 17 days after IDF soldier Gilad Shalit was abducted in Gaza, opened a second front on Israel's northern border, including barrages of Katyusha rockets and mortar shells.

Prime Minister Ehud Olmert declared the attack as an "act of war" and not terror. During a press conference with Japanese Prime Minister Junichiro Koizumi Wednesday afternoon, he called it an unprovoked assault by a sovereign nation and held Lebanon, where Hizbullah has a minister in the government, fully responsible.


In the cold calculations of the roiling furnace that is the Middle East, few cool heads are to be found.

Some days, it's easy to think there's not an ice cube's shot in hell that a solution can ever be found to quell the flames.

Update: Israel launches strikes and ground troops against Lebanon in response.

Labels: