Wednesday, March 07, 2007

Auto-da-Fidel

[posted by Callimachus]

Bravo to Nat Hentoff for keeping up the pressure on this story of the American Library Association's shameful refusal to say a word against its beloved Fidel Castro -- even as he throws Cuban librarians in cages.

The American Library Association —the largest organization of librarians in the world — continually declares that it fights for everyone's "Freedom to Read!" and its Library Bill of Rights requires its members to "challenge censorship." Yet the leadership of the ALA — not the rank and file — insistently refuses to call for the immediate release of the independent librarians in Cuba — designated as "prisoners of conscience" by Amnesty International. They are serving very long prison terms because they do believe in the freedom to read — especially in a dictatorship.

Among the many organizations demanding that Fidel Castro and his successors release these courageous Cubans — who have opened their homes and libraries to offer books censored in the Cuban state libraries — are such groups as the library associations of the Czech Republic, Latvia, Estonia and Poland. All these librarians, finally freed from Communism, agree with their colleagues in the Polish Library Association, who say in their declaration, "The actions of the Cuban authorities relate to the worst traditions of repressing the freedom of thought and expression."

... However, the top officials of the American Library Association —as well as the majority of its Governing Council —speak derisively of these "so-called librarians" in Castro's gulags.

As far as I can tell, Hentoff is a lonely voice in working this story. Not that he'd care. I first caught his column on it months ago, when he wrote about the tiny Vermillion, S.D., public library that bucked the big national organization and made the independent Dulce Maria Loynaz Library in Havana a sister library, sending it books, including a collection of Mark Twain.

The ALA appears to be intransigent on the issue. It's not that they're unaware of it. It's that they'd rather trust Fidel.

It's true that these prisoners, many brutalized and in failing health, in their cells, don't have master's degrees in Library Science; but as poet-novelist-educator Andrei Codrescu told last year's ALA Midwinter Conference: "These people have been imprisoned for BEING librarians!" Why dismiss them "as 'so-called librarians' when clearly there is no one (in that dictatorship) to certify them."

... A key ALA official, Judith Krug, heads its office of Intellectual Freedom. In my many years of reporting on the ALA's sterling record of protecting American librarians from censorship, I often quoted her in admiration. But now, she said at an ALA meeting about supporters of the caged librarians, "I've dug in my heels ... I refuse to be governed by people with an agenda." The Cuba issue, she continued, "wouldn't die," though she'd like to "drown it."

The agenda, Ms. Krug, is freedom.

Labels: , ,

Tuesday, June 28, 2005

Flag Quotes

Nat Hentoff (can't find this one online) writes a column about HJR 10, the Flag Desecration Amendment, that gathers three excellent quotes that express my view of the thing.

First, watching the House debates on C-SPAN, Hentoff hears Democrat Artur Davis of Alabama.

Opposing the amendment, he told of how his grandmother used to say to him that, even after the Supreme Court ruled in Brown v. Board of Education that segregation in public schools was unconstitutional, she would see, "riding through rural Alabama, crosses burning." But, added Congressman Davis, "Those burning crosses did nothing to slow the progress of justice. So, too, the people who would burn flags, like those who burnt crosses, have lost. Our values have been deep enough to withstand the worst ideas."

More pithy is this quote by Bobby Scott (D-Va.), speaking of anyone foolish enough to burn the flag:

"How ridiculous it is to protest the very symbol of his right to protest! We don't need protection from anyone who does that."

Finally, he cites March 1994 comments by Congressional Medal of Honor recipient Sen. Bob Kerrey, who lost a leg in the Vietnam war, during an earlier bout with an anti-flag-burning amendment:

"Real patriotism cannot be coerced. It must be a voluntary unselfish brave act to sacrifice for others. And when Americans feel coercion, especially from the government, they tend to rebel. So none of us should be surprised ... that one unintended consequence of enacting this law will be an increased occurrence of flag desecration."

Labels: , ,

Monday, January 31, 2005

Book Report

Nat Hentoff finds a library in South Dakota that is shipping books to an independent Cuban library, one of more than a dozens that Fidel Castro's thugs raided in 2003, confiscating all the books that the dictator didn't want people to read, and burning them.

Yes, burning them. The government still burns books in the Cuba Che Guevara made, while we make movies apotheosizing Che as a liberator. At least, in this one case, they didn't throw the librarian in jail for 20 years, too.

On Nov. 18, the Vermillion Public Library Board of Trustees voted to sponsor the Dulce Maria Loynaz Library in Havana, Cuba, which, like other imperiled independent libraries in that country, offers public access to books not obtainable in Cuba's censored "public" library system.

They sent down Spanish-language editions of Harry Potter and Mark Twain; not a bad place to start over. What's so remarkable, though is that Vermillion, S.D., is "the first, and only, American public library to stand up to Fidel Castro."

In January 2003, the governing council of the American Library Association, the largest such organization in the world, expressed rhetorical concern for the 75 imprisoned Cuban dissidents, but shamefully rejected a motion calling for the immediate release of the librarians who are among the 75, all of whom Amnesty International has rightly called "prisoners of conscience."

This decision by the American Library Association's governing council to not overly displease the Cuban dictator was due to Castro admirers on the council who laud him, for instance, for providing health care for his subjects, but who also ignore his contempt for Cubans who think for themselves.

And in Castro's prisons -- as U.N. High Commissioner for Human Rights representative Christine Chanet has reported -- at least 20 of the prisoners of conscience have been suffering from hypertension, diabetes, heart disease and other ailments with little or no medical attentions (since 1989, Castro has barred the International Red Cross from his prisons).

I don't understand why not one other American library has joined Vermillion in sponsoring a sister independent library in Cuba. This country's librarians have been among the most publicized dissenters to the Patriot Act provision that allows the FBI -- on the authorization of the secret Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court, without probable cause -- to find out which library patrons are reading which books.

Yet, librarians here will be in no danger of being imprisoned by showing solidarity with beleaguered courageous Cuban librarians. And it's not as if the Vermillion library's action is little-known. Steve Marquardt, dean of libraries at South Dakota State University, has informed every U.S. state library association newsletter about it.


The librarians of America, of course, can be bothered to go to bat for the real victims of repression, such as Michael Moore:

BUZZFLASH: Now specifically, a little bit about your book [Stupid White Men]. You've written in your columns that after September 11th, your publisher was going to deep-six the book unless you took out critical comments on Bush. You held firm. Is it true that the librarians of America came to your defense and saved the day?

MICHAEL MOORE: That's what it looks like. I mean, I didn't know who any of these people were. They -- this one librarian found out about it, and she got in a, I don't know, library chat room. Or she sent a letter out to a list of librarians, and they sent it out to a bunch of people, and the thing kind of mushroomed from there. So, I'd say it's a combination of these librarians and the Internet, because they started sending letters to Harper-Collins, and Harper-Collins saw that it wasn't gonna be a good thing to ban the book. But I'm really happy about it. I really didn't realize the librarians were, you know, such a dangerous group.

Labels: , ,